Locked in
Without a Sermon
Good Morning on this fine blustery, spirit-like day. This
past Friday night, I was at
Eighth Day Books working on my sermon. I had been
reading and writing throughout the day, but I still had no idea what I was
going to preach. It was 8:30 in the evening; the Eighth Day staff had gone
home; and I was locked in the bookstore…. On purpose, mind you, not by
accident. I wasn’t trapped or anything. Warren Farha, the owner, is very
generous and thoughtful. He lets me stay late when I am working. I just let
myself out when I am finished.
Anyway, I was struggling with what I was going to
focus on in today’s sermon, really struggling with how to even begin it, when I
looked up. There across this room filled with books, was a book whose title
caught my eye: Sermons that Work.
“Holy cow,” I thought, “I could sure use one of those.” So I walk over, picked
up the book, and read the full title: Sermons
that Work: Ten Prize-Winning Episcopal Sermons. The hair stood up on
the back of my neck. If this isn’t a sign from God, then I don’t know what is.
I begin feverously flipping through its pages to see if there might just happen
to be a ready-made sermon on John, chapter three: Genesis 22, Genesis 18, Mark
6, John 21,… I go through all ten sermons, but not a single one has anything to
do with John 3.
But maybe, just maybe I could modify one of these
award-winning sermons. I flip to the beginning of one sermon and read, “When I
was in the Navy in the Philippines…” Well, that’s no good. I’ve never been in
the Navy, nor have I ever gone to the Philippines. So I turn a few pages more, and the next
sermon begins with, “My great aunt’s name was Lolo.” I did have a grandmother
we used to call Momo, but no Great Aunt Lolo. “Oh well,” I said to myself, “I
guess I better just bite the bullet and write my own sermon.” But as I think
back, finding that book wasn’t a total loss, it may not have given me a sermon,
but it did give me a way to begin.
Enter
Nicodemus
And, it raises a question. Was seeing that book of sermons
a sign from God, or not? Perhaps it was just my unconscious self pointing me in
that direction, because it knew I needed a sermon, and it had seen the book out
of the corner of my eye? Or perhaps it was all just a coincidence? But how do
we know? How do we decide? How do we determine when something is from God, and
when it isn’t?
These are the questions that kept Nicodemus up
late at night. These are the questions that compelled him to leave his house
after dark in order to seek a clandestine audience with this Jesus of Nazareth,
this new Jewish rabbi who has been causing such a stir. Is Jesus from God, or
not?... And, does it even matter?
Well, it mattered to Nicodemus; it mattered a lot,
in fact. For Nicodemus, it was a matter of life and death, not just for him
personally, but for the nation. You see, Nicodemus was a leader among the
Jewish people; he had some political responsibilities. He was also a Pharisee,
a man devoted to studying and living out God’s law, something that had become
increasingly difficult in a world that was being taken over and shaped by those
pagan Romans. And now, he is faced with another dilemma. Jesus of Nazareth has
been performing some noteworthy signs, but where do they point? Do they point
to God, or somewhere else?
For example, Jesus attended a village wedding in
Cana of Galilee. It was reported that on the third day of the celebration, he
turned water into wine. And it wasn’t just a small amount of water; it was a
hundred and fifty gallons worth. And it wasn’t just any water, it was the water
used in Jewish rites of purification. The Pharisees had worked so hard to
remain pure and undefiled. They had also worked hard to get all the Jews to
live pure and undefiled lives as well, all in the hopes that God would finally
forgive his wayward people and send his Messiah to rescue them. And now, this
Jesus had transformed ritual water into wine. And not just any wine, the best
they had ever had. Was this a sign from God?
It sure seemed like it, until Jesus went up to
Jerusalem to celebrate Passover. He was visiting the temple, when suddenly he
started going about like a crazy man. He made a whip and drove out all of the
vendors and the sacrificial animals. “Take these things out of here!,” he
shouted, “Stop making my Father’s house a marketplace!” Many people believed in
Jesus because of these signs, but some didn’t (2:23).
Nicodemus seems genuinely undecided. On the one
hand, Jesus turned water into wine, but on the other hand, he engaged in a
public demonstration against the temple. Is Jesus from God, or not? Does he
speak for God, or not? These are tricky questions because Nicodemus would no
doubt have been familiar with some Old Testament texts that warned God’s people
against being taken in by false prophets. For example, in Deuteronomy 13 we
read:
1 If
prophets… appear among you and promise you omens or portents, 2 and the omens or the
portents declared by them take place, and they say, “Let us follow other gods…
and let us serve them,” 3
you must not heed the words of those prophets…; for the Lord your God is testing you, to know whether you indeed
love the Lord your God with all
your heart and soul. 4
The Lord your God you shall follow,
him alone you shall fear, his commandments you shall keep, his voice you shall
obey, him you shall serve, and to him you shall hold fast. 5 But those prophets…
shall be put to death…. So you shall purge the evil from your midst (Deut 13:1–5).
Then, in Deuteronomy 18, the Lord God, speaking to Moses, says:
Any prophet who… presumes to speak in my name, a word
that I have not commanded the prophet to speak—that prophet shall die” (Deut 18:20).
So the question of who Jesus is, is a tricky one.
It is not as simple as pointing to his miracles because it is just possible
that he is a false prophet trying to lead the people astray. So how is Nicodemus
going to decide if this Jesus speaks and acts on God’s behalf? It’s critical
that he make the right decision, because if Jesus really is from God, then he
must be followed and obeyed. But if not, then he needs to be eliminated. There
is no middle ground. And so, Nicodemus goes to meet Jesus, but he does so at
night because he doesn’t want anybody to know.
Enter
Jesus
Shifting gears a bit, I have a question for you: Have you
ever been in one of those conversations where the other person keeps changing
the subject?—Perhaps I should also ask, have you ever been that person?—Anyway,
you know the sort of conversation I am talking about. You feel like you are
always trying to catch up. You are never quite able to get a word in edgewise,
maybe a question here or a head nod there. And when it is all over, you feel a
bit exhausted and a bit confused.
I wonder if that’s how Nicodemus felt when he was
talking to Jesus, or rather, when he was listening to Jesus talk, because Jesus
pretty much takes over the conversation from the very beginning. Each man
speaks three times, but Nicodemus’ contributions get shorter and shorter, while
Jesus’ get longer and longer. Granted, if you had the opportunity for a
one-on-one conversation with Jesus, I think you would want to listen more than talk. But the problem is, Jesus
keeps changing the subject, so that even we readers of the story sometimes find
it hard to follow the logic and flow of Jesus’ thought.
For example, Nicodemus begins the conversation
very politely by saying,
Rabbi, we know that you are a teacher who has come
from God; for no one can do these signs that you do apart from the presence of
God (3:2).
To which, Jesus responds:
Very truly, I tell
you, no one can see the kingdom of God without being born from above (3:3).
Well, Nicodemus hadn’t
said anything about the kingdom of God, but he goes along with it, and he responds with a couple of questions.
How can anyone be
born after having grown old? Can a person enter a second time into the mother’s womb and be born? (3:4)
Jesus picks back up with talking about the kingdom of God,
but now, instead of talking about being born “from above,” he talks about being
born “of water and the Spirit.” “What is born of the flesh is flesh,” Jesus
says, “and what is born of the Spirit is spirit” (3:6). Then, when Nicodemus asks, “How can these
things be?,” Jesus leaves off talking about the kingdom and the Spirit
altogether and instead begins talking about snakes in the desert, the Son of
Man being lifted up, and about eternal life.
I should say that I don’t really think that Jesus
keeps changing the subject, but he does employ a variety of metaphors to refer
to the same reality: seeing the
kingdom of God, being born again, having eternal life, being saved. He also employs a number of stark
contrasts: heavenly and earthly; spirit and flesh; life and death; light and
darkness. These contrasts suggest that there is no middle ground when it comes
to Jesus. Today, there isn’t time to explore these images, metaphors, and
contrasts in detail, but they will reappear in the weeks ahead as we listen in
on Jesus’ conversations with other individuals—a Samaritan woman, a blind man,
and the sisters of Lazarus. But today, the question we must answer is this:
Through all of these images and metaphors, what is Jesus trying to convey to
Nicodemus? What does it all boil down to?
The Point of It All
Nicodemus wants to know who Jesus is. He wants to trust
Jesus, to believe in him. He has an inkling that Jesus is from God, but he
wants a greater level of certainty because so much is at stake. But here’s the
deal, we cannot know for certain who Jesus is apart from the exercise of faith,
apart from actually putting our trust in him. Seeing with our natural eyes and
reasoning with our natural minds can only take us so far. For Nicodemus and for
us, there has to be a leap of faith. It isn’t a blind leap of faith, nor is it
an irrational leap of faith, but it is a leap of faith nonetheless.
For example, a child standing on the edge of a
table cannot know for certain that his father will catch him until he jumps and
is caught. Certainly, the child sees the father standing there with arms
outstretched. So the child has some reason to suspect that his father is
willing and able to catch him, but the child will never know for certain until
he exercises faith and jumps, again and again and again.
This is what Jesus offers to Nicodemus and to us.
The signs that he has been performing point to his identity as the Son of God,
but they do not constitute proof. Evidence, certainly, but nothing like
irrefutable proof, which is why some believed and some didn’t. The signs Jesus
performed were true, but ambiguous, at least when observed without the lens of
faith, without being born of the Spirit, which is itself as mysterious as the
movements of the wind. It’s there, you see the effects, but you can’t quite pin
it down. It takes faith, which is to say, that it takes submitting ourselves to
the movements and inklings of the Spirit. For you see, faith is not something
that we generate. We exercise it; we put it into practice. But faith does not
originate with us; it is a gift given to us by God. More specifically, faith is
the gift of the Spirit, that is, faith is the gift of the indwelling presence
of the Spirit. To be possessed by the Holy Spirit of God, that’s what it means
to be spiritual. That’s what it means to be born of water and the Spirit, to
see the kingdom of God. And this gift has been made possible by another gift,
the gift of God’s one and only Son who became flesh and blood for our sakes,
who submitted himself to human death, that we might have the opportunity to possess
and be possessed by God’s divine life, which is, the eternal kind of life.
What Became of Nicodemus?
There is so much more than could be said about his, but I
am sure that you are all dying to know what became of Nicodemus. Did he get his
questions answered? Did he ever figure out who Jesus was? Here’s the rest of
the story.
Nicodemus appears two more times in the gospel. In
his first reappearance, Jesus is causing another disturbance in the temple
precincts. The temple guard are dispatched to arrest him, but they are
unsuccessful. When they return to give their report, they are reprimanded by
the chief priests and Pharisees. However, Nicodemus stands up and asks, “Our
law does not judge people without first giving them a hearing to find out what
they are doing, does it?” (7:51).
His colleagues bite back, “Surely you are not also from Galilee, are you?
Search and you will see that no prophet is to arise from Galilee” (7:52). Nicodemus’ question
may not be a public declaration of allegiance to Jesus; nevertheless, he is
putting his reputation and standing at some risk by posing the question.
Nicodemus’ final appearance occurs during the
postlude of the crucifixion. Jesus is dead, his disciples are in hiding, and
his body still hangs limply on the cross. Out of the shadows come two men.
Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus. Joseph secures Pilate’s permission to
remove the body, and Nicodemus joins him, having brought along a hundred pounds
of burial spices. They prepare the body according to Jewish custom, and lay it
in a tomb. By why? Why would these two respected members of the Jewish
community risk their reputations and possibly their lives to bury a man, a
criminal, an enemy of the state who was obviously a false prophet, for the
crucifixion of Jesus was the surest sign yet that he was not from God.
Their actions just don’t make any sense, unless…
unless their eyes had been opened to see who Jesus really was, a king of a very
different sort of kingdom. And so I think we have our answer, Nicodemus’ presence
at the tomb was an exercise of faith. In the cross of Jesus, he had seen the
kingdom of God by faith, he had seen God’s love by faith, and now he was in
possession of eternal life by faith.
Thanks be to God!